This is one of the most common misunderstandings we come across. A business owner books a fire alarm service, receives a certificate, and assumes they have covered their fire safety obligations. A landlord has their alarm tested regularly and is surprised to receive an enforcement notice because there is no written fire risk assessment on file.
The two services are not the same thing. They are not interchangeable. They are not one bigger than the other. They sit under different articles of the same legislation, they cover different aspects of fire safety, and both are legally required for most commercial and residential premises in London.
This guide explains what each one involves, what the law requires, and how the two services work together to keep your building compliant and the people inside it safe.
The Short Answer: What Each Service Actually Does
Fire Safety Assessment
A comprehensive review of your entire building and everything that affects fire risk within it. Covers hazards, escape routes, fire doors, compartmentation, emergency lighting, fire fighting equipment, staff procedures, maintenance records, and your fire detection system. Governed by Article 9 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. Must be recorded in writing. Carried out by a competent assessor.
Fire Alarm Test
A check that your existing fire detection and alarm system is working as it should. Weekly tests are carried out by you or your staff by activating a call point. Six-monthly servicing is carried out by a qualified engineer who inspects and tests every component. Governed by Article 17 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 and BS 5839-1. Results must be recorded in a fire alarm logbook.
One assesses the whole building and decides what fire safety measures you need. The other checks that one specific piece of equipment is working. Both are legal requirements. Neither covers the other’s ground.
The Legal Basis: Two Separate Duties Under the Same Law
Both obligations sit under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, which is the primary fire safety legislation for non-domestic premises and the common areas of multi-occupied residential buildings in England. But they arise from different articles of that Order.
Article 9: The Fire Risk Assessment Duty
Article 9 requires the responsible person to carry out a suitable and sufficient assessment of the fire risks to relevant persons. This is the fire risk assessment, sometimes also called a fire safety assessment. It must identify every hazard present, evaluate the risk level, and set out what fire safety measures are needed. Since Section 156 of the Building Safety Act 2022, it must be recorded in writing for all premises covered by the Order, without exception.
The fire risk assessment does not just look at your alarm. It looks at everything: the layout of the building, the materials it is constructed from, the number and mobility of people who use it, the means of escape, fire door integrity, emergency lighting, extinguisher provision, staff training, and maintenance records. The alarm is reviewed as one element within this broader picture, but it is only one element.
Article 17: The Maintenance and Testing Duty
Article 17 requires the responsible person to ensure that fire safety measures, including the fire detection and alarm system, are maintained in an efficient state and working order. For fire alarm systems, this duty is given practical content by British Standard BS 5839-1 (for non-domestic premises), which sets out the testing schedule that responsible persons are expected to follow.
The testing duty is ongoing and repetitive. Weekly, six-monthly, and annual testing cycles are built into the standard. The fire risk assessment is a periodic review; alarm testing happens continuously throughout the year.
What a Fire Safety Assessment Covers
A fire safety assessment is a top-to-bottom review of your premises. A competent assessor will examine:
- All ignition sources present in the building
- All fuel loads, including combustible materials, furnishings, and building fabric
- The presence and condition of fire detection and alarm systems, including whether the system type and coverage is appropriate for the building
- Whether emergency lighting covers all escape routes and is regularly tested to BS 5266
- The condition and compliance of all fire doors, including gaps, seals, self-closers, and ironmongery
- Whether escape routes are clear, accessible, properly signed, and adequate for the number of people using the building
- The provision and positioning of fire extinguishers, and whether they are the correct type for the fire risks present
- Fire compartmentation throughout the building, including any penetrations or alterations that may have compromised it
- Staff fire safety training and the currency of fire evacuation procedures
- All maintenance records, including alarm testing logs, extinguisher service records, and emergency lighting test results
At the end of the assessment, you receive a written report. This sets out every finding, assigns a risk rating to each issue, and gives you a prioritised list of actions. That report is your legal documentation of compliance with Article 9. It is what the London Fire Brigade will ask to see if they inspect your premises.
The fire safety assessment tells you what you need. It does not check whether the things you already have are working. That is what the fire alarm test does.
What a Fire Alarm Test Covers
Fire alarm testing is not a single event. It is an ongoing programme with three distinct components.
Weekly Test: Your Responsibility
Under BS 5839-1, the responsible person or a designated member of staff should test the fire alarm system weekly. The standard way to do this in a commercial building is to activate a manual call point, checking that the alarm sounds as expected. A different call point should be tested each week so that all zones and call points are cycled through over time.
This test confirms the system activates and sounds. It does not check individual detector heads, wiring, battery back-up, or control panel programming. But it does catch obvious faults and keeps staff familiar with the alarm sound.
The result of every weekly test must be written in the fire alarm logbook. An absence of test records is one of the most common compliance failures identified during London Fire Brigade audits.
Six-Monthly Service: A Qualified Engineer
At least every six months, a qualified fire alarm engineer should carry out a full inspection and service of the system. This goes significantly further than the weekly call point test. The engineer will:
- Test every detector head in the building to confirm it responds correctly
- Test every manual call point
- Check all control panel functions, including fault indicators and zone displays
- Test battery back-up power
- Inspect all wiring and connections for deterioration or damage
- Check that any connection to an alarm receiving centre or monitoring service is functioning
- Record all findings in a service certificate that must be kept on file
After the service, the engineer will advise whether the system needs any repairs or component replacements. Acting on that advice is part of your Article 17 maintenance obligation.
Annual Review: Aligning With Your Assessment
Once a year, the fire alarm system should be reviewed against the fire risk assessment to confirm that it is still appropriate for the building and its occupancy. If the building has been altered, if new high-risk areas have been created, or if occupancy has changed significantly, the assessment may indicate that the alarm system needs to be extended or upgraded. This is a good example of why the two services are connected: the annual fire alarm review makes most sense when it happens alongside or shortly after the annual fire safety assessment review.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Fire Safety Assessment | Fire Alarm Test |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | Article 9, RR(FS)O 2005 | Article 17, RR(FS)O 2005; BS 5839-1 |
| What it covers | The whole building — all fire hazards, all safety measures | The fire alarm and detection system only |
| Frequency | At least annually, plus after significant changes | Weekly (staff), six-monthly (engineer), annually (full review) |
| Who carries it out | A competent fire risk assessor | Responsible person (weekly); qualified fire alarm engineer (six-monthly) |
| Output document | Written fire risk assessment report with action plan | Fire alarm logbook entries; six-monthly service certificate |
| Checks fire doors? | Yes | No |
| Checks escape routes? | Yes | No |
| Checks emergency lighting? | Reviews provision and records | No |
| Checks alarm system? | Reviews type, coverage, and maintenance records | Tests components directly |
| Can substitute for the other? | No | No |
Why Having One Does Not Mean You Have the Other
This is where the confusion most commonly arises. A business that has been diligently testing its fire alarm every week and having it serviced twice a year may still have no written fire risk assessment and be in breach of Article 9. The alarm testing record does not constitute, or substitute for, a fire risk assessment in any legal sense. If the London Fire Brigade inspects and asks to see the written fire risk assessment, a fire alarm logbook will not satisfy that request.
The reverse is also possible, though less common. A building with a thorough, up-to-date fire risk assessment may have fallen behind on alarm testing because the responsible person did not realise they were required to keep a logbook or arrange six-monthly professional servicing. The assessment recommends that the alarm is properly maintained. Actually maintaining it, and keeping the records to prove it, is a separate, ongoing task.
A Real-World Illustration
Imagine a landlord who manages a converted Victorian house in London, let to four tenants as an HMO. The landlord arranged a fire alarm installation when the licence was first granted, and has the alarm tested every six months by the company that installed it. The certificates are on file.
During a London Fire Brigade inspection, the officer asks to see the written fire risk assessment. The landlord produces the alarm service certificates. The officer explains that those certificates confirm the alarm is working, but they do not constitute a fire risk assessment. The inspection also identifies that two fire doors in the property do not close properly, and that there is no emergency lighting in the stairwell.
Neither of those issues would have been identified by the alarm test. A fire safety assessment would have identified all three problems. The landlord leaves the inspection with an enforcement notice for failing to have a fire risk assessment and for inadequate fire doors and emergency lighting.
How the Two Services Connect
A fire safety assessment and fire alarm testing are not in competition. They are genuinely complementary, and understanding how they connect helps you manage both obligations more efficiently.
The Assessment Tells You What System You Need
The fire risk assessment reviews whether your current fire detection and alarm system is appropriate for the building and the risks present. It considers the building’s size, layout, occupancy type, and escape strategy, and determines whether the existing system provides adequate coverage and the right type of detection.
If the assessment finds that your alarm is insufficient, for example that a Grade D system is present where the building’s size and layout require a Grade A or B system, that finding must be acted on. Simply continuing to test a system that is fundamentally inadequate for your building does not discharge your obligations.
The Alarm Test Keeps the System the Assessment Specified in Working Order
Once the assessment has confirmed that the right system is in place, regular testing ensures it continues to work. An alarm that is never tested may fail silently. A detector head that fills with dust over months may stop responding to smoke without anyone noticing. The weekly test and six-monthly service catch these issues before they become a crisis.
Testing Records Are Reviewed During the Assessment
When a competent assessor carries out your annual fire safety assessment review, one of the things they will check is whether the alarm system has been tested and serviced in accordance with BS 5839-1 and the requirements of the previous assessment. If you cannot produce a fire alarm logbook with regular weekly entries and a current service certificate, that is an action point in the assessment report.
This means your testing records feed directly into your assessment compliance. Keeping the logbook up to date is not just a maintenance task. It is part of demonstrating that your fire safety management system is functioning correctly.
The False Alarm Problem: Why a Well-Maintained Alarm Also Matters Beyond Testing
There is a practical consequence of alarm maintenance that goes beyond legal compliance. According to the London Fire Brigade’s automatic fire alarm policy, in 2023/24 automatic fire alarms made up 40% of all incidents the Brigade attended, at around 52,000 calls. Of those, less than 1% were actual fires. The remainder were unwanted signals, the majority caused by poorly maintained or incorrectly specified systems.
From October 2024, the London Fire Brigade stopped attending most daytime automatic fire alarm activations in commercial buildings unless a person also calls to confirm a fire. This means that if your alarm activates due to a maintenance fault during working hours, the Brigade will not automatically attend. Your staff and your evacuation procedures become the primary response, and a poorly maintained alarm with a history of false activations risks creating the dangerous situation where a real activation is dismissed as another false alarm.
A properly maintained alarm, specified correctly by a competent assessor and serviced to BS 5839-1, produces far fewer false activations. That is one of the practical reasons why the two services, assessment and testing, work best when they are managed together.
What This Means in Practice for London Landlords and Business Owners
If you are responsible for a commercial premises, an HMO, a residential block, or any other building covered by the RR(FS)O, you need both services in place.
- A current, written fire risk assessment reviewed at least annually and updated whenever significant changes occur
- Weekly fire alarm call point tests carried out by you or your staff and recorded in a logbook
- Six-monthly professional fire alarm servicing by a qualified engineer with a certificate kept on file
If you have your alarm tested but no written assessment, you are in breach of Article 9. If you have a current assessment but no alarm testing records, you are in breach of Article 17. Both attract enforcement action from the London Fire Brigade.
The quickest way to confirm whether you have both in order is to ask yourself two questions. First: can I produce a written fire risk assessment, dated within the last twelve months, that accurately reflects this building? Second: can I produce a fire alarm logbook showing weekly test entries and a service certificate dated within the last six months? If the answer to either is no, that is where to start.
Need a fire safety assessment or fire alarm testing in London?
Pro Fire Safe provides both services for businesses, landlords, and property managers across London. Our fire risk assessment service produces a full written report and action plan. Our fire alarm testing service covers installation, regular servicing, and compliance documentation. Contact us on 0207 205 7337 or email admin@profiresafe.co.uk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a fire safety assessment and a fire alarm test?
A fire safety assessment is a comprehensive review of your entire building covering all fire hazards, means of escape, fire doors, emergency lighting, fire extinguishers, and your fire detection system. It is governed by Article 9 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 and must be carried out by a competent assessor and recorded in writing. A fire alarm test checks that your existing fire detection and alarm system is working. The weekly call point test is carried out by you or your staff. The six-monthly professional service is carried out by a qualified engineer. They are completely separate requirements under different articles of the same legislation.
Does having a fire alarm test mean I do not need a fire safety assessment?
No. A fire alarm test confirms that your alarm system is functioning. It does not assess whether you have the right type of alarm for your building, whether your escape routes are adequate, whether your fire doors comply, or whether your emergency lighting covers all required areas. All of those matters are covered by the fire safety assessment. Both are required under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, and neither substitutes for the other.
How often should a fire alarm be tested in a commercial building?
Under BS 5839-1, fire alarm systems in commercial and non-domestic premises should be tested weekly by the responsible person or a designated member of staff, typically by activating a different call point each week. A professional service by a qualified engineer is required at least every six months. A full annual inspection and review is also recommended. All testing must be recorded in a fire alarm logbook.
How often does a fire safety assessment need to be carried out?
Annual review is the standard expectation under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. The assessment must also be reviewed whenever there is a significant change to the building, a change in the number of people using it, following a fire or near miss, after refurbishment works, or whenever new fire safety legislation comes into force. The assessment must always be kept up to date and must reflect the current condition of the premises.
Who carries out a fire alarm test and who carries out a fire safety assessment?
Weekly fire alarm tests are carried out by the responsible person or a trained staff member. Six-monthly servicing and annual inspection must be carried out by a competent fire alarm engineer. A fire safety assessment must be carried out by a competent person with sufficient knowledge and experience to identify fire hazards and evaluate risk across the whole building. For most commercial premises and residential blocks, this means a qualified fire safety assessor rather than a general contractor or the responsible person themselves.
What happens if the fire safety assessment identifies a problem with the fire alarm?
The fire safety assessment reviews whether the fire alarm system is appropriate for the building and adequate for the level of risk. If the assessment identifies that the system is the wrong type, does not cover all required areas, or has not been serviced correctly, those issues will appear as actions in the written report. You are then required to address them within a reasonable timescale. Arranging regular fire alarm testing and servicing is one of the actions most commonly recommended in fire safety assessments where alarm maintenance records cannot be produced.